Star Trek XI Plot Holes

posted on March 6th, 2010, 4:59 pm

Nemesis just got a listing of the plot holes, I think it's time the most recent Star Trek movie got it's plot torn to pieces. How many plot holes can you find?

posted on March 6th, 2010, 5:08 pm

no, just no, if i listed all the plot holes of that i would be 50 before i completed it.

posted on March 6th, 2010, 5:16 pm

It won't take that long, pretty quick actually.

Star Trek XI Plot Holes:
1. Star Trek XI

posted on March 6th, 2010, 8:48 pm

of course, the worst plot hole, nice one tyler.

the whole film completely destroys all of the canon after enterprise. so anytime you want to quote canon you have to quote enterprise  tuvok dead  illogical

posted on March 6th, 2010, 9:03 pm

of course, the worst plot hole, nice one tyler.

the whole film completely destroys all of the canon after enterprise. so anytime you want to quote canon you have to quote enterprise  tuvok dead  illogical

And one more that can't and probably didn't even wanted to listen...

posted on March 6th, 2010, 9:35 pm

the whole film completely destroys all of the canon after enterprise.

I keep wondering why people around here seem to just not want to get it. 
Has anyone ever heard the word "reboot"?
ST XI was never meant to be canon since it was meant to rewrite ST itself since it is a reboot.
To complain about how not-canon ST XI is just shows you didn't get this one but crucial point.

posted on March 6th, 2010, 11:09 pm

i get its point, i just didnt like it >:(

trek needed to change to survive, a reboot could have been done well, abrams got it compeltely wrong, he could have done a tasteful reboot but his skill was not enough.

posted on March 7th, 2010, 12:48 am

Abrams actually perverted Star Trek into a summer-action movie. That's all what it is.
A movie for a standard-allswallowing-audience who likes noise, explosions, one-dimensional drawen remakes of great characters and the absolute braindead long for revenge of one man who wants to kill the ones who wanted to help and save his world but simply failed. Of course. I would LOVE to kill people who failed in something they actually worked for 

posted on March 7th, 2010, 1:17 am

Man, you guys are spot on.  I mean, look at some of these reviews!  I feel this really captures what you're trying to say.

posted on March 7th, 2010, 9:17 am

Man, you guys are spot on.  I mean, look at some of these reviews!  I feel this really captures what you're trying to say.

One smiley: 

posted on March 7th, 2010, 2:58 pm

Lol Tyler, I think we might be able to enjoy Nemisis now, if only because its plot holes aren't nearly as big as the plot holes (or as they're known in the film "Black holes" or "Nonsense Lightning Storms in Space") Star Trek XI used to destroy Vulcan, A cool Romulan ship, and a sensible timeline.

posted on March 7th, 2010, 3:33 pm

It's to easy for people to scream plot-holes but not actually back up what they say. I bet many of the things you say are plot-holes really are not and can be explained. Also we have to remember that this is a different time-line were things have changed, so using "canon" to justify something is nearly impossible.

posted on March 7th, 2010, 6:11 pm

In my opinion the enterprise itself is the plothole number 1.

If a design  engineer would build such a ship today, in some nations he would get shoot instantly. The ship was much bigger then the orginal enterprise. ok. But this waste of space was beyond  comprehension.

I think I remember a half deck stair at kirk dads ship.
I mean, on military ships today, there are small stairs to conect the decks. But that was a huge metal constuktion with such a waste of space...

And the engine room. OMG. It was like a refinery just with water in glasspipes! Why the hell they should use glasspipes?!? And it was huge like a today hangar. Star Trek engine rooms where always strange. But this one was completly stupid. Just build a ship today with such a engine room and you are fired. And nobody was home!

On the one hand the ship wasted space because it was build like a cruise  liner and on the other hand it wasted space because it was build like a big industry park without somebody controling the thing

And this adrenalinejunkie redshirt... There was some sort of education at star fleet academy?

posted on March 7th, 2010, 6:45 pm

In my opinion the enterprise itself is the plothole number 1.

Everybody, would you please read this?!

And then I'd like to know how the Enterprise can be a plothole 

posted on March 7th, 2010, 7:02 pm

Because the construction of the ship is against all rules of logic. 
And it was build on a planet not in space...