Types of games allowed on the Replay Thread

[Dominus_Noctis]

posted on June 9th, 2011, 5:34 pm

Last edited by Dominus_Noctis on June 13th, 2011, 1:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.

Please dont post AI games here. They are boring to play and to watch! Better get on tunngle and play MP games. Thanks.

Dom edit: split from Star Trek Armada II: Fleet Operations - List of awesome youtube replays by request and desire to keep on target . Discusses whether one should post just MP games or AI games too for replays.

posted on June 9th, 2011, 5:49 pm

Please dont post AI games here. They are boring to play and to watch! Better get on tunngle and play MP games. Thanks.

do you know what you sound like? ai replays are replays too, and have as much right to be here as player v player replays. if u dont wanna watch them then dont watch them, nobody's gonna put a gun to your head and make you do anything.

posted on June 9th, 2011, 6:03 pm

ai games are great just as well! My favorite are the tournament games!

posted on June 9th, 2011, 6:47 pm

Drrrrrr

I believe I speak for the commentators when I say that is uncalled for.  This is a thread for youtube replays, and these replays meet both of those requirements.  You have no right to tell him what replays can or cannot be posted there.  This is not the way to encourage new commentators. 

Yandonman's first replays had neither sound nor multiple people perhaps you have forgotten that. One of Yandons First replays.

This is just as much of a place to post my replays as it is for Gorandius.

@ Gorandius, Great to see you putting up replays, keep it up!

posted on June 9th, 2011, 6:55 pm

Drrrrrr

I believe I speak for the commentators when I say that is uncalled for.  This is a thread for youtube replays, and these replays meet both of those requirements.  You have no right to tell him what replays can or cannot be posted there.  This is not the way to encourage new commentators. 

Yandonman's first replays had neither sound nor multiple people perhaps you have forgotten that. One of Yandons First replays.

This is just as much of a place to post my replays as it is for Gorandius.

@ Gorandius, Great to see you putting up replays, keep it up!

Epic

posted on June 9th, 2011, 7:33 pm

Agreed with Ray.  The replay thread is for all replays and always has been.  No one is forcing anyone else to watch them.  This is the place for all.

posted on June 10th, 2011, 5:52 am

Great, so if AI replays can go here I invite TCR to post all the replays he probably made from his AI maps. Games where a stupid AI throws masses and masses of Borg ships gainst ppl turtling up. How awesome is this? Not awsome? Then it should not go here (See thread title).

posted on June 10th, 2011, 6:00 am

Feel free not to watch them, Drrrr.

  Your 'taste' in replays is not what decides what replays go in this thread .  Thankfully.  I suggest you let this go before you offend people or hurt anyone's feelings.

posted on June 10th, 2011, 8:00 am

Drrrrrr

Again you have no right to dictate who post's here.  I speak for the commentators when I say this is a place for replays, Gorandius and Tcr have every right to post them here.  Your opinions are irrelevant to what this thread is for, posting replays.  However, if we are to take your literal interpretation, that this thread is only for a "List of awesome youtube replays" then why are you posting your thoughts here, obviously its irrelevant to the topic at hand?  Either way its irrelevant.


Bottom Line: His replays stay, and will continue to be posted.

Comments like yours are not good at encouraging new members to stay, or commentators,  and I have no appreciation for them, nor do I believe the community does.  I do encourage you however, to stop while you are ahead, you have full control to watch what replays you will.

posted on June 10th, 2011, 10:50 am

agreed with boggz and ray last 2 posts.

if we bother to ban "non awesome" replays, we cant even define "non awesome". who gets to decide what's awesome and whats not. definitely not one person.

so i underscore ray's bottom line, his replay doesnt fit what YOU want, but it fits what others (who are probably less likely to post) want. his replay belongs here as much as yandon's. i dont see you demanding yandon to delete his early ai replays.

posted on June 10th, 2011, 11:49 am

I very rarely post but I will speak up here. Replays are one of my favorite things about this community and the more the better. Please, Gorandius, feel welcome to post yours.

posted on June 10th, 2011, 12:39 pm

Great, so if AI replays can go here I invite TCR to post all the replays he probably made from his AI maps.

It will still be more replays than you've ever put up.  BA-ZING!!!
I invite you to start.

posted on June 10th, 2011, 3:11 pm

I tried to make a replay once. It didn't go so well Laaagg

posted on June 10th, 2011, 3:23 pm

So many apple polishers here :|
You dont have to encourage new ppl like that. They are likely not retarded and can speak for themselves. Also, I just made a single comment in a thread that contains dozens of MP replays...for a good reason, because SP is plain boring. Its not even good to practice for anything but turtling games. And if all the people would start to post pointless replays here, the thread would be trashed soon (like it is now because of your outrage).

The initial meaning afaik of this thread was to get MP replays' some attention. You can count the SP replays here with one hand I guess. From that absolutly valid point of view I made my comment (because I thought it is also obvious for other ppl that MP are placed here).

posted on June 10th, 2011, 3:40 pm

So many apple polishers here :|
You dont have to encourage new ppl like that. They are likely not retarded and can speak for themselves. Also, I just made a single comment in a thread that contains dozens of MP replays...for a good reason, because SP is plain boring. Its not even good to practice for anything but turtling games. And if all the people would start to post pointless replays here, the thread would be trashed soon (like it is now because of your outrage).

The initial meaning afaik of this thread was to get MP replays' some attention. You can count the SP replays here with one hand I guess. From that absolutly valid point of view I made my comment (because I thought it is also obvious for other ppl that MP are placed here).

keep digging drrrrr, keep digging, you'll strike oil soon.

this isnt about whether sp replays are fun or not, this is about your post. which for starters was rude. but more importantly, you dont get to decide who has right to post replays here. the initial meaning of this thread was to post replays, that is all. no rule about what replays, and sp replays belong here just as much as mp replays.

now i think this sillyness has gone on long enough, let's try get this thread back to its purpose of being a place for replays, not an argument.